Introduction
If Black Clover worked for you because of Asta’s relentless climb, the Black Bulls’ chaotic teamwork, and battles built around different magical abilities, the best follow-up is not simply another fantasy anime with magic. The more useful question is which part of Black Clover you want to experience again.
Some viewers want another dysfunctional but dependable squad. Others care more about an underdog protagonist, a long-running rivalry, a large fantasy world, or fights where ability matchups matter. The five picks below keep those priorities separate, so you can choose based on what you actually liked most about Black Clover.
Quick List: Best Anime Like Black Clover
- Fairy Tail — The closest overall choice if the Black Bulls, magic-user organizations, and team-based adventures were your favorite parts.
- My Hero Academia — Best if you were most invested in Asta starting at a disadvantage and earning his place through training and persistence.
- Naruto — Choose this if Asta and Yuno’s rivalry and long-term battle-shonen growth mattered most.
- Magi: The Labyrinth of Magic — A stronger fit if the expanding magical world and fantasy adventure interested you more than squad competition.
- Hunter × Hunter (2011) — Best if you want ability-based battles with more emphasis on conditions, matchups, and tactical decisions.
1. Fairy Tail
Why Fairy Tail Is the Closest Overall Match
Fairy Tail is the easiest transition for viewers whose favorite part of Black Clover was the Black Bulls rather than Asta alone. Both series rely on groups of highly individual fighters with very different abilities and personalities.
The connection is clearest in team battles, where different abilities solve different problems and the group matters as much as the strongest fighter.
If You Liked the Black Bulls
If you enjoyed seeing the Black Bulls function as a team despite their clashing personalities, Fairy Tail is the most familiar option here.
The biggest difference is emphasis. Fairy Tail leans more heavily into friendship, guild bonds, and comedy, while Black Clover keeps Asta’s individual climb and the competitive Magic Knight structure more visible.
Best for: Viewers who want another magic-based series where an eccentric group of teammates matters almost as much as the lead character.
2. My Hero Academia
If Asta’s Underdog Growth Was the Main Appeal
My Hero Academia changes the setting completely, but it preserves one of Black Clover’s strongest character hooks: a protagonist who begins from a position that makes his goal unusually difficult.
Much of Asta’s appeal comes from watching him enter spaces filled with gifted people, prove that he can contribute, and expand what he can do. My Hero Academia offers similar progression through training, competition, and harder challenges.
Rivalry Without Copying Black Clover
The lead is also surrounded by talented peers who create pressure to improve, making progress easy to feel through constant comparison.
The main difference is the world. Instead of kingdoms, magic, and knight squads, My Hero Academia uses a modern superhero society and school-based training structure. If fantasy itself is essential, Fairy Tail or Magi is the better choice.
Best for: Viewers who cared most about Asta earning recognition and improving beside stronger or more naturally gifted peers.
3. Naruto
For Fans of Asta and Yuno’s Rivalry
Naruto is the strongest pick here for viewers who saw Asta and Yuno’s rivalry as one of Black Clover’s main engines. In both series, a strong peer gives the protagonist a visible standard to chase and turns personal growth into an ongoing comparison.
Like Asta, Naruto seeks recognition despite being doubted, while teammates, mentors, and rivals develop across a long journey.
If You Want a Longer Growth Journey
Naruto is particularly suitable if you liked how Black Clover keeps adding stronger opponents and broader conflicts while still returning to the characters’ original ambitions.
The biggest tradeoff is length and setting. Naruto is built around ninja, missions, and its own combat system rather than magic knights, so viewers wanting a more immediately magical follow-up may prefer Fairy Tail or Magi.
Best for: Viewers who want another long battle shonen centered on recognition, rivalry, teammates, and gradual progression.
4. Magi: The Labyrinth of Magic
If the Clover Kingdom Made You Want a Bigger Fantasy World
Magi is for viewers who finished Black Clover wanting more fantasy exploration rather than another version of Asta. Its strongest connection is the experience of entering a world where magic, different nations, powerful individuals, and competing interests shape the adventure.
Compared with Fairy Tail, Magi is less about staying with one guild-like group. It places more weight on discovering how different parts of its fantasy world work.
What This Anime Does Differently
Black Clover often expands outward from the Magic Knights and Clover Kingdom; Magi makes exploration and encounters with different cultures and powers more central.
Do not start here expecting another Asta-style underdog story or direct equivalent to Magic Knight squad competition. Start here if the magical setting itself was one of the reasons you kept watching Black Clover.
Best for: Viewers who want magic, adventure, new regions, and a fantasy world that feels larger than a single organization.
5. Hunter × Hunter (2011)
For More Tactical Power Battles
Hunter × Hunter is the least obvious match on the surface, but it becomes much more convincing if you liked Black Clover battles because different powers could interact in unexpected ways.
As its combat systems develop, understanding an ability can matter as much as raw strength. Conditions, timing, information, and matchups can change a fight.
The Biggest Difference
Hunter × Hunter does not give you a direct substitute for the Black Bulls. Its characters move through changing environments and challenges rather than remaining centered on one large squad.
It is less suitable for viewers mainly seeking squad chemistry, but stronger for those who want battles that reward attention to rules and decisions.
Best for: Viewers who want more tactical fights where understanding how powers work is part of the fun.
Which Anime Should You Watch First?
If You Miss the Black Bulls Most
Start with Fairy Tail. It most directly recreates the experience of spending time with a loud, unconventional group of magic users who become effective because of their differences.
If Asta’s Progress Was Your Favorite Part
Choose My Hero Academia. The setting is very different, but its progression works best for viewers who enjoyed watching someone begin with a major disadvantage and gradually prove that he belongs among talented peers.
If Asta and Yuno Kept You Invested
Go with Naruto. It is the strongest option for a long-running rivalry, a protagonist seeking recognition, and a cast whose growth unfolds over a substantial journey.
If You Want More Fantasy Exploration
Pick Magi: The Labyrinth of Magic. It moves away from squad structure and puts more energy into magic, travel, nations, and the expansion of its fantasy world.
If You Want Smarter Ability Matchups
Start Hunter × Hunter (2011). It is the most different choice here, but the best fit if Black Clover made you want fights where rules, limitations, and tactical decisions matter more.
Related Anime Recommendations
Conclusion
For most Black Clover fans, Fairy Tail is the best first choice when the goal is to replace the combination of magic, eccentric teammates, and group battles. It comes closest to the Black Bulls side of the experience without simply copying Black Clover’s central character dynamic.
If Asta himself was the main reason you kept watching, My Hero Academia is the more focused follow-up. If the Asta-Yuno rivalry and long-form shonen progression mattered more, Naruto is the better route. Magi makes more sense for fantasy-world exploration, while Hunter × Hunter is the strongest step toward more tactical ability battles.